Clean beauty fans tend to seek out an eye pencil that won’t be too harsh on the lids. One product that’s mentioned in that search is Mesmerize Eyeliner by Vapour Organic Beauty. The following is a guide to what it is, how it works, who it’s for, and some alternatives to consider.

What is Mesmerize Eyeliner?

Mesmerize Eyeliner Pencil is Vapour Organic Beauty’s organic eyeliner pencil. It has a soft formula which is blendable and has a smudging tool on the opposite end of it. The brand claims to be formulated with 70% certified organic ingredients, and it is suitable for sensitive eyes. Wear time is mixed, as it’s best suited for those who prefer clean ingredients over a long-term color.

Mesmerize Eyeliner Product Overview

It’s an organic eyeliner pencil and on the other end of the pencil there’s a smudging tool. It’s a pencil for lining and softening – that’s two-in-one!

It states that it does not contain any of the toxic chemicals that most eyeliners contain, and that 70% of the ingredients are certified organic. That’s the primary reason to pick out Mesmerize Eyeliner over a standard drug store pencil. 

Note on the name: “Mesmerize” is a little too dark to be found in another brand’s collection. According to the Cosmas description, Mesmerize is a soft lilac matte shade, part of its Soul Gazer gel eyeliner line. It’s a different product. This article will be about Vapour Organic Beauty pencil. 

The most important characteristics of Mesmerize Eyeliner.

This is what the brand and retailers trumpet about this pencil.

Soft, blendable texture. One retailer says that the color is deep, rich and blendable, and glides on without pulsing on delicate lids. 

Soothing ingredients. It has coconut and chamomile as soothing and nourishing ingredients. 

Organic binders. The pencil is made with organic binders instead of the harsh adhesives found in conventional eyeliners. 

Built-in smudger. The smudging tool is used to soften lines or create a smoky effect without using a brush.

Small size. The net weight is 0.027 oz (0.784 g). This is not a lot of product, considering the price. 

The steps for using mesmerize eyeliner are quite simple.

With any soft pencil here are a few simple habits that will help you maximize performance.

Use a clean and dry lid.

The best line will be with a freshly sharpened, fine-tipped pencil. 

Make short light strokes along the lash line, and join them together.

If a smoky effect is desired, use the smudging tool to soften the edge.

Liner above the eyeshadow (eyeshadow won’t overpower the line). 

For people with hooded or small eyes, leave the line thin. A thick line can cause the eye to appear smaller. To create a more intense color, make it in layers, rather than pressing down heavily.

Who is Mesmerize Eyeliner for?

You may want to use Mesmerize Eyeliner if:

You want an organic or “clean” eye pencil.

You have sensitive eyes. According to one retailer, it’s good for all skin types, particularly sensitive eyes. 

You have a preference for a soft pencil that you can smudge.

You like a “plain” pencil rather than a liquid or gel.

It might not work for those who require liners that are waterproof and fit for all day use. Typically, soft, natural pencils require touch-ups and the following section discusses the implications of this here. 

Pros and Cons Based on Reviews

When buying any product, reviews on Mesmerize Eyeliner are far from being all positive, so it is always better to see both sides.

Reported pros

One reviewer liked that it did not irritate the eyes, was vegan and organic, and was travel friendly. 

The same reviewer indicated that the smoky eye tool is good. 

Reported cons

This reviewer did not find that it was easy to apply, the pigment was weak, and it faded after several hours. 

It was also considered to be costly for the amount of it, rating it at 1.5/5. 

Another reviewer on MakeupAlley stated that she was cold with the Truffle shade, even though she wanted to endorse the brand. 

Remember that these are personal views. The results may differ depending on the color, eye shape and use. Nevertheless, if longevity is a primary concern, survey a couple of recent reviews before making your purchase. 

Price and Where to Buy

The price varies by store and area, please check the current listing. One older listing had the price of $20 at Credo Beauty and The Detox Market. Well.ca listed it at $24.96. Purchase from the brand or from an authorized dealer to ensure that you are getting the freshest or not fake product. 

Similar Alternatives to Mesmerize Eyeliner

If Mesmerize Eyeliner is not working for you, try these… Make your selections by what is most important to you.

Kosas Soulgazer Gel Eyeliner

If staying power is what you desire this is the choice for you. Kosas’s Soulgazer gel eyeliner is designed to be a waterproof gel liner that glides on in one stroke and sells for $24. Another retailer says it is retractable, has a built-in sharpener and smudger and has a creamy non-tugging feel. The downside: gel liners are different from the traditional pencil. 

Any other pencil which is made of organic or natural material.

Check the pencils for ingredients that are plainly written and that they say they are soft and won’t tug into the hair. If you have sensitive eyes, look for fragrance-free formulas. Like Mesmerize Eyeliner, many natural pencils come with the same problem of being mild on the eyes, but may require a touch-up.

Normal kohl or gel pencils

If the time of wear is a greater concern than ingredients, perhaps a traditional smudge-proof pencil will last longer. Test on your hand before use. If you tend to be irritated, it’s also a good idea to do patch testing.

Liquid liners

Sharp, graphic line, like a wing, from liquid liner. More skill is required than with a pencil and cannot achieve the smoky effect that Mesmerize Eyeliner achieves. 

How to Choose the Right Eyeliner

Ask yourself three quick questions:

• How long do I need it to last? Choose gel or waterproof formulas for long days.
• How sensitive are my eyes? Choose gentler, simple formulas and patch test first.
• What finish do I want? Soft pencils suit smoky looks. Liquids suit sharp lines.

This approach keeps you from paying for features you will not use.

Tips to Make Any Soft Pencil Last Longer

Soft pencils can fade, but small steps help.

• Prime the lid so oils do not break down the line.
• Set the line with a matching powder shadow.
• Skip heavy creams or oils near the lash line before you apply.
• Keep the pencil sharp, and store it in a cool place.

These tips can help Mesmerize Eyeliner and similar pencils perform better, though none of them will turn a soft pencil into a waterproof one.

Final Thoughts

Mesmerize Eyeliner is a thoughtful choice if clean ingredients and gentle application matter most to you. The soft pencil, the built-in smudger and the organic formula are its strongest points. The small size, the price and mixed reviews on wear time are the main drawbacks.

If you want a soft, smoky look and your eyes are easily irritated, Mesmerize Eyeliner is worth considering. If you need a smudge-proof line from morning to night, a waterproof gel option such as Kosas Soulgazer may serve you better.

Whichever you pick, check the latest reviews, patch test first, and buy from a trusted seller. The best eyeliner is the one that fits your eyes, your routine and your budget.

FAQs

What is Mesmerize Eyeliner?

Mesmerize Eyeliner is an organic eye pencil from Vapour Organic Beauty. It comes with a smudging tool on one end and is made for soft, blendable definition.

Is Mesmerize Eyeliner good for sensitive eyes?

Retailer descriptions say it suits all skin types, especially sensitive eyes. Everyone reacts differently, so do a patch test and stop use if you notice irritation. 

Is Mesmerize Eyeliner waterproof?

The sources I found do not describe Mesmerize Eyeliner as waterproof. Treat it as a soft pencil that may fade, and choose a waterproof gel liner if you need all-day wear.

Does Mesmerize Eyeliner last all day?

Reviews are mixed. One reviewer said it faded after a few hours. Priming the lid and setting the line with powder shadow may help. 

Is the Kosas Mesmerize shade the same product?

No. The Kosas Mesmerize shade is a lilac gel liner from a different brand. Always check the brand name before you buy.